Severance Negotiations for Executives: Equity, References, and Reputation

An executive’s departure isn’t like an ordinary termination or resignation. The stakes are exponentially higher—your compensation structure is complex, your public reputation is on the line, and your next opportunity may depend on how gracefully (and strategically) you navigate your exit.

Unlike rank-and-file employees, executives operate under contracts that intertwine base salary, performance bonuses, stock options, deferred compensation, and restrictive covenants like noncompetes and nondisclosure agreements (NDAs). Each of these elements can have lasting financial and career consequences. The severance package you sign today can determine not just what you take with you, but also what opportunities remain open to you down the road.

Adding to the complexity, Michigan’s employment landscape is changing. Recent legal trends—including proposed restrictions on noncompete agreements and heightened scrutiny of employer practices by courts and regulators—are reshaping how severance and exit contracts are enforced. This evolving environment gives executives both new leverage and new risks when leaving an organization.

In this climate, severance negotiations are not just about “closing the chapter”—they’re about preserving your legacy, protecting your financial interests, and positioning yourself for the next opportunity.

Understanding Executive Severance Agreements in Michigan

A severance agreement is a legally binding contract between an employer and an employee that outlines the terms of separation when employment ends. For executives, however, it’s far more than a simple paycheck after departure—it’s a blueprint for how your transition, compensation, and reputation will be managed long after your last day in the office.

What’s in an Executive Severance Agreement?

While standard employee severance packages might include a few weeks of pay and a release of claims, executive agreements are much more complex and tailored. They often include:

• Base salary continuation or lump-sum payments based on tenure or performance.
• Bonus and incentive payouts tied to corporate milestones or personal performance metrics.
• Equity and stock options, including provisions for accelerated vesting, deferred compensation, or restricted stock units (RSUs).
• Health and benefit extensions, often continuing executive-level coverage for a set period.
• Noncompete and confidentiality clauses, which can restrict where and how you work next.
• Mutual non-disparagement and reference provisions, designed to protect your professional reputation.

Executives Aren’t “At-Will” in the Traditional Sense

Michigan is generally an at-will employment state, meaning employers can terminate most employees at any time, for any reason that isn’t illegal. But executives often operate under employment contracts that modify that default rule.

Your contract might specify:

• What constitutes “cause” for termination.
• Conditions under which severance pay is owed.
• How long you must remain available for consultation or transition.
• What rights you retain to deferred compensation or bonuses.

Key Laws That Govern Executive Severance

Several Michigan and federal laws intersect in executive severance agreements, including:

• Michigan Contract Law: Interprets how terms are enforced and what constitutes a breach or bad faith negotiation.
• ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act): Governs retirement and benefit plans, including deferred compensation and severance pay in certain cases.
• ADEA (Age Discrimination in Employment Act): Requires special language and timelines for employees over 40, including a 21–45 day review period and a 7-day revocation window.
• SEC and Securities Regulations: Apply to executives of public companies, particularly regarding insider trading, disclosure, and timing of stock sales.

The Three Pillars of a Smart Executive Exit: Equity, References & Reputation

Equity — Protecting What You’ve Earned

For most executives, equity is the real compensation. Stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), and deferred compensation can easily outweigh base salary and bonuses. But when a termination or transition occurs, these assets are often the first—and easiest—for a company to take back.

Key issues include:

• Vesting schedules and “accelerated vesting” clauses: Most equity vests over time, often with performance triggers or annual dates. If you’re terminated before your next vesting date, you could lose years of value.
• Unvested equity upon termination: Companies may try to cancel unvested shares immediately. Negotiating prorated or accelerated vesting can preserve what you’ve already earned.
• Tax consequences and payout timing: A misstep in when or how equity is paid can trigger unexpected taxes, especially with deferred compensation under Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code.

Always review your plan documents—not just the severance letter. Stock and incentive plans often contain hidden restrictions or forfeiture clauses that override general severance terms.

Example: If your stock options vest on December 31 and you’re let go on December 15, two weeks could cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars.

References — Controlling the Narrative

For executives, the way your departure is described can matter more than the severance itself. A neutral or positive reference clause can protect your reputation and career trajectory.

Many companies default to vague “policy statements” such as, “We only confirm dates of employment and position held.” On paper, that may seem harmless—but in practice, it can leave future employers wondering what really happened.

To avoid this ambiguity, request clear, contractual reference language that:

• Requires the company to provide a factual, non-disparaging reference when contacted.
• Allows for a mutually approved statement or joint announcement if your exit is public-facing.
• Ensures consistency across HR files, internal communications, and LinkedIn or press releases.

Reputation — Protecting Your Name After You Leave

At the executive level, reputation is currency. How your departure is handled—and how it’s discussed—can impact board opportunities, speaking engagements, and future roles. That’s why confidentiality and non-disparagement provisions deserve close scrutiny.

Pay special attention to:

• Confidentiality and NDAs: Overbroad nondisclosure agreements can unfairly silence you while allowing the company to speak freely. Limit NDAs to legitimate business interests, not public perception management.
• Mutual non-disparagement: Insist that the company is also prohibited from making negative statements about you. If you’re agreeing to keep quiet, so should they.
• Public and shareholder communications: In executive roles, your departure may trigger required disclosures. Review and approve any language that mentions your performance or conduct.
• Clawback and “for cause” provisions: Be alert for language that lets the company reclaim severance or equity if they later claim you violated an undefined “policy.”

Negotiation Strategy: Leverage, Timing, and Tone

Timing Matters

Under federal law, executives over the age of 40 are generally entitled to 21 days (or up to 45 days in group layoffs) to review a severance agreement before signing, followed by a 7-day revocation period under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). Even if you’re younger or not covered by the ADEA, most employers will allow a short review window.

Don’t rush it. Use that time to consult with an employment attorney, review every clause carefully, and identify negotiation opportunities before the ink dries. Once you sign, you’re bound by the terms—no matter how unfair they may seem later.

Leverage Points That Matter

A strong negotiation strategy begins with understanding your leverage. Even if your termination wasn’t voluntary, you may have more influence than you think.

• Company Risk Exposure: If your departure involves potential claims—like discrimination, retaliation, or whistleblower concerns—your leverage increases. Employers often prefer to resolve those quietly through favorable severance terms rather than risk litigation or bad publicity.
• Institutional Knowledge & Transition Value: As an executive, you hold critical information and relationships that the company needs for a smooth transition. Use this responsibly as leverage—your cooperation has value.
• Reputation Management for the Company: Senior-level exits draw attention. Companies often want to control the narrative and maintain investor or employee confidence. In exchange for your cooperation, you can negotiate better terms around payment, reference language, or non-disparagement.

Tone Is Everything

The tone you take in severance discussions can make or break the process. Professional, calm, and confident is far more effective than combative or emotional. Remember—you’re negotiating from a position of leadership, not desperation.

Keep the focus on fairness and mutual respect. The goal isn’t to “win” but to secure an agreement that honors your contributions, protects your reputation, and allows both sides to move forward without conflict. Having counsel handle direct communications often helps preserve that professional tone while maximizing results.

When the Job Ends, Your Negotiation Begins

Your severance agreement is more than a paycheck—it defines your professional legacy. It determines not only what you take with you financially, but also how your departure is perceived, how your story is told, and how easily you move into the next phase of your career.

You’ve worked hard to build your reputation, your equity, and your standing in your industry. Don’t let a rushed or one-sided agreement take that away. Every clause—from equity vesting to reference language—can carry long-term consequences for your finances and your future opportunities.

Before you sign anything, make sure you understand your rights and the leverage you hold. With an experienced employment attorney by your side, you can turn a difficult transition into a strategic negotiation—one that protects everything you’ve built.

If you’re an executive in Michigan facing a termination, exit, or forced resignation, contact Batey Law Firm, PLLC today. We’ll help you protect your compensation, your reputation, and your future.

📍 30200 Telegraph Rd, Suite 400, Bingham Farms, MI 48025
📞 248-540-6800 🌐 www.bateylaw.com
✉️ sbatey@bateylaw.com